ACM Awards
2006 – Top New Female Vocalist
2006 – Single Record Of The Year (Jesus, Take The Wheel)
2007 – Top Female Vocalist
2007 – Album Of The Year (Some Hearts)
2007 – Video Of The Year (Before He Cheats)
2008 – Top Female Vocalist
2009 – Entertainer Of The Year
2009 – Top Female Vocalist
2010 – Triple Crown Award
2010 – Entertainer of the Year

American Music Awards
2006 – Favorite Breakthrough Artist
2007 – Favorite Country Female Artist
2007 – Favorite Country Album (Some Hearts)
2007 – Artist Of The Year
2008 – Favorite Country Album (Carnival Ride)

Billboard Music Awards
2005 – Hot 100 Singles Sales (Inside Your Heaven)
2005 – Top Country Singles Sales (Inside Your Heaven)
2005 – Top Country Singles Sales Artists
2006 – Top Billboard 200 Female Artists
2006 – Top Billboard 200 Albums (Some Hearts)
2006 – Top Female Country Artists
2006 – Top New Country Artists
2006 – Top Country Albums (Some Hearts)
2007 – Top Billboard 200 Female Artists
2007 – Top Country Artists
2007 – Top Female Country Artists
2007 – Top Country Album Artists
2007 – Top Country Album (Some Hearts)
2008 – Top Country Songs Artists
2000s – Country Album of the decade (Some Hearts)

CMA Awards
2006 – Female Vocalist Of The Year
2006 – Horizon Award
2007 – Female Vocalist Of The Year
2007 – Single Of The Year (Before He Cheats)
2008 – Female Vocalist Of The Year

CMT Music Awards
2006 – Female Video Of The Year (Jesus, Take The Wheel)
2006 – Breakthrough Video Of The Year (Jesus, Take The Wheel)
2007 – Video Of The Year (Before He Cheats)
2007 – Female Video Of The Year (Before He Cheats)
2010 – CMT Performance of the Year (Temporary Home - from Invitation Only)
2010 – Video of the Year (Cowboy Casanova)

GMA Awards
2006 – Country Recorded Song Of The Year

Grammy Awards
2007 – Best New Artist
2007 – Best Female Country Vocal Performance (Jesus, Take The Wheel)
2008 – Best Female Country Vocal Performance (Before He Cheats)
2009 – Best Female Country Vocal Performance (Last Name)
2010 – Best Country Collaboration with vocals (I Told You So feat. Randy Travis)

Inspirational Country Music Awards
2006 – Mainstream Country Artist

Music Row Magazine Awards
2006 – Critics’ Pick (New Artist Award)

NARM Awards
2006 – Country Breakout Artist Of The Year

People’s Choice Awards
2007 – Favorite Female Singer
2007 – Favorite Country Song (Before He Cheats)
2009 – Favorite Star Under 35
2009 – Favorite Female Singer
2009 – Favorite Country Song (Last Name)
2010 – Favorite Country Artist

2000s: 1 | 2005: 3 | 2006: 16 | 2007: 19 | 2008: 5 | 2009: 6 | 2010: 6
Total: 56